NEW SHOW FEATURE: We are now LIVE streaming our shows. Want to join us live? Just click this link every Friday at 3pm ET / 12pm PT.
In this episode of The Soul of Enterprise, Ron and Ed welcome Dr. Jeffrey A. Singer, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute and a seasoned general surgeon, to discuss his latest book, Your Body, Your Health Care. Dr. Singer delves into the erosion of patient autonomy in the modern healthcare system, attributing much of it to increasing government intervention. He advocates for a return to a patient-centered approach, emphasizing informed consent and individual sovereignty in medical decisions. The conversation explores the historical shift from medical paternalism to patient rights, critiques current regulatory frameworks, and offers insights into policy reforms that prioritize personal choice and freedom in healthcare.
AI SHOW NOTES (while our editor is still out)
Live Broadcast Segment Planning
Ed, Ron, and Jeffrey discussed the logistics of a live broadcast, including technical setup and the need for clear communication during breaks. Jeffrey shared his background, including his medical training and eventual move to Arizona, while Ed and Ron prepared for their segments. They agreed on the format for the show, with Ron and Ed trading off segments, and Jeffrey was informed of the live nature of the broadcast, emphasizing the importance of adhering to "Nixon rules." The show was set to begin, with Ed introducing the segment and expressing excitement about having Jeffrey as a guest.
Patient Autonomy in Healthcare Policy
Dr. Jeffrey Singer, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute and a practicing surgeon, discussed his book "Your Body, Your Healthcare," which explores how government interference undermines patient autonomy in healthcare decisions. He explained that his book reframes healthcare policy debates through the lens of individual liberty, drawing on his clinical experience to make complex issues accessible to a general audience. Singer highlighted the historical shift from medical paternalism to patient autonomy, using the case of Mary Schloendorff to illustrate this evolution. He emphasized that while doctors now respect patient autonomy, governments often infringe on this right by regulating medical practices and patient choices.
Medical Licensing as Protectionism
Dr. Jeffrey Singer explained how licensing laws, particularly for doctors, often serve as protectionist policies that limit competition rather than genuinely protect the public. He shared a hypothetical scenario where a licensed surgeon attempts to switch to psychiatry, only to find that private organizations like hospitals, insurance companies, and malpractice carriers restrict practice based on board certification rather than basic medical licensing. Singer traced the history of medical licensing to the 19th century, showing how the American Medical Association successfully lobbied for state licensing laws to exclude competitors, and discussed how this has created a cartel-like system that limits alternative payment models and healthcare delivery methods.
FDA's History and Political Influence
Dr. Jeffrey Singer discussed the history and impact of the FDA, noting that while its original purpose was to prevent fraud, subsequent regulations have often delayed access to medications and been influenced by political considerations. He criticized the Maha report, co-authored with Terence Keeley and Bautista Vivanco, for being poorly researched and driven by preconceived conclusions, particularly regarding the role of ultra-processed foods in health issues. The discussion also touched on the FDA's history of regulating prescription and over-the-counter medications, highlighting how political pressures and special interests have shaped drug accessibility.
Addressing Homelessness and Healthcare Barriers
Jeffrey discussed the challenges of addressing homelessness, emphasizing the need to respect individual autonomy in mental health treatment while acknowledging the complexities of the issue. He highlighted the role of factors such as zoning laws, affordable housing shortages, and regulatory barriers to accessing effective medications like clozapine. Jeffrey also addressed the impact of certificate of need laws, which he believes hinder competition and drive up healthcare costs, and he expressed optimism that some states might repeal these laws despite resistance from entrenched interests.
Podcast Plans
The meeting focused on a recent podcast featuring Dr. Jeffrey Singer from the Cato Institute, who discussed their research paper on the MAGA report and its impact, including being cited in Rolling Stone and other media outlets. Ed and Ron expressed interest in featuring Terrence Keeley on a future episode to discuss his work on government regulation, and Jeffrey offered to make an email introduction.
Bonus Content is Available As Well
Did you know that each week after our live show, Ron and Ed take to the microphone for a bonus show? Typically, this bonus show is an extension of the live show topic (sometimes even with the same guest) and a few other pieces of news, current events, or things that have caught our attention.
Click the “FANATIC” image to learn more about pricing and member benefits.